Why Vinyl Still Matters: Understanding the Format That Refuses to Die

There’s something improbable about vinyl when you really think about it. A diamond needle tracking microscopic wiggles in a plastic disc, somehow reproducing the kick drum from Carl Craig’s ‘Bug in the Bass Bin’ or the sweeping pads of Boards of Canada with decent fidelity. It seems unlikely, but it works through straightforward engineering that, even 77 years after Columbia Records launched the first 12-inch LP at the Waldorf-Astoria Hotel in June 1948, still feels worth understanding properly.

The vinyl revival has brought a new generation into the fold, but even seasoned collectors who’ve been dropping needles for decades might not fully grasp what’s actually happening when that stylus hits the groove. Understanding the process doesn’t diminish the experience. It just adds another layer of appreciation for a format that’s managed to stick around, outlasting several digital formats that were supposed to render it obsolete.

At its most fundamental level, a vinyl record is a physical representation of sound waves, carved into a continuous spiral groove that winds its way from the outer edge to the centre of the disc. If you were to unravel that groove on a standard 12-inch LP, you’d have roughly 500 metres of audio information to work with. The groove itself is narrow, typically between 0.04 and 0.08 millimetres wide depending on the signal level, and it’s designed in a V-shape with the point facing downward. Each wall of that V carries its own channel of audio information, with the outer wall handling the right channel and the inner wall carrying the left.

The scale of what’s encoded in those grooves is pretty remarkable. The information can be stored in areas as small as a micron, which is one-thousandth of a millimetre, and it’s this microscopic precision that explains why turntables are so sensitive to vibrations and why proper isolation matters for anyone serious about their vinyl playback. A footfall across a dodgy floorboard can become a problem in the groove.

Before any of this music can reach your ears, it has to get onto the record in the first place. The process begins with a master recording, which is cut onto a lacquer disc using a cutting lathe. This is where the original sound waves are physically etched into the medium, creating a master that will be used to produce metal stampers. These stampers are then pressed into heated vinyl to create the records we buy. Unlike digital formats that chop sound into binary code, vinyl captures analogue waveforms directly, which some argue preserves more of the original recording session.

When you drop the needle, you’re beginning a complex chain of events that happens in real time, right there on your turntable. The stylus, typically made from industrial diamond, sits in the groove and follows those microscopic undulations as the record spins. Standard playback speed is either 33⅓ RPM for albums or 45 RPM for singles, and that consistency of rotation is crucial for maintaining proper pitch and timing.

The stylus is mounted on a cantilever (tone arm), a small shaft that transfers the stylus’s movements back to the cartridge. This is where the conversion happens. There are two main types of cartridge designs, moving magnet and moving coil, and both work on the principle of electromagnetic induction. In a moving magnet cartridge, a small magnet is attached to the end of the cantilever, and as the stylus tracks the groove variations, the magnet moves past fixed coils, inducing an electrical current. Moving coil cartridges work inversely, with the coils attached to the cantilever and the magnet remaining stationary. Moving coil designs typically offer better resolution but at a higher cost and with lower output voltage.

The electrical signal that emerges from the cartridge is weak, sometimes as low as a thousandth of a volt compared to the 2 volts you’d get from a CD player. This is where the phono stage enters the picture, and its role is more crucial than many people realise. The physical limitations of vinyl mean that the audio signal has to be manipulated before it’s cut to the master disc. Low frequencies are reduced in level while highs are boosted, following a standardised curve established by the RIAA. Without this equalisation, you simply couldn’t fit enough information into the groove without making the disc impractically large or causing the stylus to jump out during playback.

The phono stage reverses this RIAA curve, boosting the bass and flattening the treble to restore the signal to its intended frequency balance. If you’ve ever accidentally plugged a turntable into a line-level input, you’ll know exactly what happens without proper RIAA equalisation. You get a thin, bright sound with virtually no low end, and it’s so quiet you can barely hear it. A good phono stage not only applies the correct equalisation but also provides the amplification needed to bring that tiny cartridge signal up to line level, where your amplifier can take over and drive your speakers.

This entire process, from groove to speaker, is mechanical and electrical in nature. There’s no sampling, no conversion to digital code (unless you’re deliberately digitising your records), and no buffering. The music exists as a continuous, physical entity in the groove, and the playback is happening in real time. This gives vinyl its particular character, that sense of directness and connection to the source material.

The argument about whether vinyl sounds better than digital has been running since the compact disc arrived in 1982, and it’s not going away. Technically speaking, digital audio can achieve accurate reproduction within the limits of human hearing, assuming the sampling rate is high enough. The Nyquist-Shannon sampling theorem tells us that if you sample at twice the frequency of the highest audio you want to capture, you can recreate that signal effectively. In practice, this means a 44.1kHz sample rate (standard for CDs) can reproduce everything up to about 22kHz, which is beyond what most people can hear anyway.

But technical specifications don’t tell the whole story. Many listeners find vinyl’s presentation more natural and engaging. Part of this comes down to mastering. Records often receive different masters than their digital counterparts, sometimes with less compression and more dynamic range. The limitations of the format actually force mastering engineers to be more careful, particularly with low frequencies that can cause physical problems during cutting and playback.

There’s also something about the physical object itself that matters more than we might admit. The weight of a record in your hands, the slight give of the vinyl as you hold it by the edges, the way the light catches the grooves when you angle it just right. These aren’t incidental details. They’re part of what makes vinyl feel personal in a way that digital files never quite manage. You can’t hold an MP3, can’t flip it over to see what the B-side offers, can’t pass it to a mate saying “you need to hear this” with the same sense of occasion.

Anyone who’s spent their Saturdays flicking through record shop crates knows this feeling intimately. There’s a particular rhythm to it, that methodical working through the racks, the quick assessment of each spine, the moment when you spot something promising and pull it out for closer inspection. Sometimes you’re hunting for something specific, that white label you heard someone drop three weeks ago at Fabric, the original pressing of a classic you’ve only ever owned on CD. Other times you’re just browsing, open to whatever turns up, and those sessions often yield the best discoveries. The shop itself becomes part of the experience, whether it’s somewhere like Phonica in Soho or a dusty second-hand spot where everything smells faintly of damp cardboard and possibility.

Finding that elusive tune after months of searching, or stumbling across something you didn’t even know existed, creates a connection to the music that’s fundamentally different from adding tracks to a Spotify playlist. You’ve invested time, effort, and usually a fair bit of cash. You’ve physically gone somewhere, talked to people, made decisions. The record you walk out with carries all of that with it. And when you finally get it home and drop the needle, there’s a satisfaction that goes beyond just hearing the track. You’ve earned it, in a sense.

This might sound romantic, and perhaps it is, but it’s also practical. Vinyl forces you to be selective. You can’t own everything, so you choose carefully. You develop relationships with certain labels, certain shops, certain sounds. You learn to trust your instincts, to take chances on records based on nothing more than the artwork or the fact that it’s pressed on a particular imprint. Sometimes you get it wrong and end up with something terrible, but that’s part of it too. The misses make the hits feel better.

There’s also the social aspect of vinyl that doesn’t really have a digital equivalent. Records get passed around, borrowed, lent out and sometimes never returned. You’ll take a box of records to a mate’s house and spend an evening trading tunes, pulling out things you think they need to hear, listening to what they’ve found. It’s a form of communication, a way of sharing taste and knowledge that feels more substantial than sending someone a link. The record exists in physical space, moves between people, accumulates a history. You might write the price you paid on the sleeve, or the name of the shop where you found it, or just leave it unmarked and let it tell its own story through the inevitable scuffs and wear that accumulate over time.

Yes, vinyl is clunky. It’s heavy, fragile, inconvenient, and requires dedicated equipment and space. You can’t take your collection jogging, can’t access it from your phone while you’re on the bus. The format’s limitations are obvious and numerous. A single 12-inch record holds maybe 20 minutes of music per side if you’re lucky, compared to the thousands of hours available on any streaming service. Records skip, they warp, they attract dust, they get scratched. The whole system is outdated by any reasonable measure, a solution to a problem we’ve long since solved in more efficient ways.

But those limitations create value of their own. The fact that you can only fit so much music on a record means artists and labels have to think carefully about what makes it onto the vinyl release. Track selection matters. Sequencing matters. The format imposes discipline. And for listeners, those same constraints mean you engage differently with the music. You can’t skip through 30 tracks in five minutes. You put on a record and you listen to it, or you don’t bother at all.

The physical nature of vinyl also creates a different sense of ownership. When you buy a record, you own it completely. There’s no subscription to maintain, no service that might decide to pull the track from its catalogue, no concern about file formats becoming obsolete. The record will play in 50 years exactly as it plays today, assuming you’ve looked after it. There’s something reassuring about that permanence, particularly in an era where so much of our media consumption feels temporary and contingent.

For those of us who’ve been in the game since the acid house days, vinyl is more than just a playback medium. It’s the way we discovered music, the format we learned to beatmatch on, the physical artefact we’d hunt for in record shops from Soho to Berlin. White labels, test pressings, dubplates cut at 45 RPM for maximum impact on club systems, these things matter. They’re part of electronic music’s DNA, and they carry a weight that digital files don’t possess, regardless of how convenient the alternative might be. The ritual of carrying your record bag to a gig, the process of selecting what to play based on actual physical objects rather than scrolling through a laptop, the moment when you cue up a track on the headphones and know it’s going to work perfectly, these experiences are tied to the format itself.

The younger generation discovering vinyl now might not have those specific associations, but they’re finding their own reasons for the format’s appeal. In a world where everything is instant, accessible, and disposable, vinyl offers the opposite. It’s slow, it’s considered, it’s permanent. You have to make space for it, both physically and temporally. You can’t half-arse vinyl ownership. It demands attention and care, and maybe that’s exactly what some people are looking for.

The appeal of vinyl, ultimately, is that it’s entirely unnecessary in practical terms and yet remains relevant in others. You don’t need it for convenience, or portability, or even sound quality if we’re being objective about it. But you might want it for the way it makes you engage with music, for the deliberate act of listening, for the connection to decades of musical history, for the simple pleasure of holding something real in your hands. Each record becomes a small piece of personal history, tied to where you bought it, who you were with, what you were into at the time. Digital files don’t accumulate that kind of meaning in quite the same way.

And when you understand the complexity of what’s actually happening when that diamond tip tracks those microscopic grooves, transforming physical undulations into music, it becomes clear why the format has endured. That it works well, given the right equipment and a bit of care, is testament to solid engineering from three-quarters of a century ago and to the continued appeal of analogue in our increasingly digital world. The technology might be old, the system might be clunky, but the warmth it provides, both sonically and personally, is something that can’t quite be replicated by more modern alternatives. And judging by the queues outside record shops every Saturday afternoon, there are plenty of people who’d agree.



Discover more from Decoded Magazine

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Avatar photo
About the Author

Loves long walks along the beach, holding hands and romantic 80's power ballads, partial to electronic music and likes to make the odd mix or two.